Questions directed to Swami Jyotirmayananda

 
 
 

Following are answers to some of the questions asked about Yoga and Vedanta.
You may submit your own questions by pressing here.

 

Question: Isn't happiness a by-product of living?

Answer: Happiness that is a by-product of living is material happiness, but it is not the goal. The goal in life is to acquire that happiness which is the innate nature of the soul.

Question: There are many people who are doing a great deal of service in the world and it seems they're happy. Therefore, it would seem that their happiness is a by-product.

Answer: It seems like a by-product by doing good deeds. They are removing the obstacles to happiness. It is similar to removing the clouds and the sun shines forth. The shining of the sun is not the by-product of removing the clouds, yet you may say so in a figurative way. In the same way, when a person does good things his complexes are
dissolved, and as these complexes are being dissolved, his innate happiness shines forth. So it is an unraveling of innate happiness. If happiness were not deep within oneself, then it would be a difficult predicament. There would be no liberation actually.


Question:
But people are living in this world, and it is not a happy world. All they can do is strive not to be unhappy.

Answer: That's a good beginning to avoid pain. But to the extent that you avoid pain, to that extent certain positive forms of happiness begin to appear. Not all people are equally miserable; it depends upon different levels of evolution. In the midst of all suffering humanity, there are people who have purified their minds and are therefore closer to God within themselves. They are much happier. So positive happiness does exist. But to begin with, as long as you do not have the positive happiness, it is better to avoid pain and not to be deluded by illusory happiness.

Question:
Union with God means that we would lose our personality?

Answer: It means that, yes. A simple analogy is given of a river meeting the ocean. A river enters the ocean and what happens? Does it lose or does it gain? Both. From one point of view the river loses, because it no longer carries its name, but from another point of view it becomes one with the ocean. It is like a kind of loss, which is really not a loss. You lose something that has been built on the basis of a limited mind. It is the limited mind that has evolved ego-consciousness, and the more that ego-consciousness drowns in the sweetness of love, the greater the joy.

Question:
Generally it is considered fortunate for someone to die peacefully in his sleep. However, since sleep is tamasic, isn't this really unfortunate? Is this destined for someone ruled by tamas so that he will go to hellish worlds?

Answer: Death in sleep does not necessarily mean that a person is dominated by tamas at the time of death. While tamas overpowers the body, the mind may continue to be under the influence of sattwa or rajas. Therefore, those who die in sleep may be either under sattwa or rajas and accordingly are led to higher or lower forms of consciousness (heaven or hell). From a normal point of view, a peaceful death in sleep is much better than death in a state of agony.

Further, as explained before, a sage who transcends the gunas may die in sleep, action, or meditation. In all these cases, he is beyond the gunas
and unaffected by them.


Question:
Why is it that people who try to practice self-control become irritable and impatient?

Answer: It happens because they try to practice control without understanding. Understanding is more important than trying. They try to control without using the proper technique. There is not any negative aspect of the mind that can be merely controlled. You should substitute a positive thought rather than try to drive away a negative one. In that way you are not trying to control with tension. You simply present an ideal before your mind and allow yourself to grow into it.

Question:
Are mental repression or suppression ever necessary for an aspirant?

Answer: Repression and suppression are needed to a certain degree, with the ideal of sublimation. For example, a person is very hungry and is given poisonous food. All he wants to do is eat it. You, being his friend and knowing it to be poisoned, first take it away from him whether he likes it or not. Then you begin to explain to him that the food is poisonous. The moment he understands, there is no tension. Ultimately, he thanks you.

Similarly, when the mind is dominated by anger, you want to speak all types of evil words, but by your reason you suppress it. When you suppress it, energy boils up within yourself. But try to understand that there is another project before you--by having suppressed the negative, you have opened the mind to something positive. If, however, you do not open your mind to something positive, then suppression is bad.


Question:
Can you change your mantra?

Answer: Firstly, you must realize that all mantras refer to the same Divine Self and are equal in merit. Therefore, if you change your mantra there is no harm. However, ideally you should stick to one mantra, because in this way your mind has better possibility to concentrate. If your mind develops the habit of shifting from one thing to another, then its power of concentration weakens.

It is just like a person who digs in a particular place in order to find water. After digging in one place for five feet, he feels that since he can find water elsewhere, he starts digging there. Then, he becomes further distracted and starts in another place. Although every place will give water, he never reaches it because of his distraction. He should rather dig in one place until he reaches the water.

So from that point of view, you should stick to one mantra. If you choose one and find that it is not what you wanted, there is no harm in choosing another. But once you choose it, stick to it.


Question:
Suppose you have been practicing mantra for a certain time, and then due to various circumstances you don't practice it as much. Would everything that you accomplished in practicing be lost?

Answer: No spiritual progress is ever lost. The impressions that you gathered through the repetition of mantra continue to exist in your unconscious and exert their beneficial influence. On the other hand, if you continue to keep up with your mantra, it is much better.

Question:
Isn't the purpose of a mantra to silence the mind, to keep thoughts from dominating it?

Answer: The purpose is to free the mind from its distractions and to direct it towards God, to develop a spiritual feeling. Since mantra is a short prayer and a constant affirmation of Divine Presence, if you are constantly exposing the mind to the awareness of God and that the awareness of God is within you, then it automatically works miracles in the form of elevating your mind. That is the central purpose of a mantra.

Question:
Should a person perfect his ability to practice meditation before going ahead and teaching it?

Answer: In any form of teaching, never wait to become perfect. Start teaching whatever you know and you will automatically begin to perfect yourself more. If you wait to become perfect, you will never become perfect. The secret is that the more you give, the more you receive.

Question:
Would you explain how repetition of mantra helps to control the mind?

Answer: Repetition of mantra is an effective method of controlling the mind. A mantra consists of mystic syllables or words. Sounds in a particular mantra are related to certain psychic centers in your body known as chakras. (This is a scientific fact.) Some sounds are jarring to the mind. Some sounds are melodious. Also, words have a very strong influence over the mind. Some words, when spoken in a bitter way, can hurt a person--such is the power of words, that a friendship of many years can be broken in a few seconds just by words. On that basis the science of mantra has been developed. Sages discovered special words and recorded them. For example, "Om, Om, Om," "Om Sri Ramaya Namah," "Om Namah Shivaya," and "Om Namo Narayanaya." "Om" is the root-source of all mantras, and when you chant the "Om" mantra, it creates a special vibration, which begins to promote harmony in your body and mind.

A mantra is repeated with two attitudes--firstly you repeat the mantra verbally, and secondly, you start developing a feeling that what you are repeating is the name of the Absolute Self, the name of God. So in this way, with each repetition you are invoking the presence of the Divine Self. A mantra becomes like a short prayer, or constant affirmation of Divine Presence, constantly reminding you that you are in touch with God. If you do not have a mantra and if you simply say to yourself with feeling, "I am in touch with God, I am in touch with God," it will in itself give you a sense of relaxation. But this is not a mantra. If you adopt or are initiated into a mantra, it is a more scientifically planned approach to Divinity, and practicing your mantra has a definite influence on your unconscious. Mantra has a great part in Yoga.


Question:
I know scientists who can concentrate for hours, and yet they have never repeated a mantra.

Answer: Concentration can be achieved in many ways, and mantra is one of the important ones. Academic or scientific concentration is of a different type. Its project is not research into the nature of the spirit, but research into the nature of matter.

Entering into concentration is a kind of yoga, but in order to be perfect yoga, it must be directed towards the intuitional realization of the Self. Otherwise it becomes a lesser yoga. From a broad point of view, every concentrated state of mind is yoga and every achievement is a yogic achievement. What all great people have achieved in the fields of painting, music and science, has been due to concentration of mind--and that is yoga--but the highest yoga is directing mental concentration to Self-realization.


Question:
I am having trouble reconciling working for a salary and karma yoga. I try to maintain the attitude that everything I do is for God and not to care for the fruits of labor, but the practical reality of needing a paycheck to survive tends to weaken that ideal. How can I sincerely promote this while my mind is always thinking that I am overworked, underpaid, and working for a company that is very unorganized?

Answer: Fire is preceded by smoke. If you become upset by smoke you cannot kindle fire. In the same manner, if you become upset by the limitation of work (or jobs) you cannot become adept in karma yoga. In spite of the limitations, you should continue to keep up the ideal of karma yoga to the extent it is possible. Earning a living is important to keep your mind free of that pressure, so you can direct your energy freely towards your sadhana (spiritual practice) and towards works that are more selfless and uplifting in nature.

You should have a practical insight into the job you do for earning a living. If it is possible for you to find a better and more agreeable job, you should do so. If you use your intelligence to better your economical circumstances, you are not opposing the ideals of karma yoga, because you will be placing yourself into better circumstances for practicing selfless service. At the same time, you should not give up what you already have without having secured something better.


Question:
At times when I am in meditation, I feel more drawn to the Sahasrara Chakra than I do to the Ajna Chakra. Why is meditation on this Chakra not promoted more than on the Ajna since it is higher?

Answer: Ajna and Sahasrara are interlinked. Ajna paves the way to the Sahasrara, and Sahasrara helps to perfect the unfoldment of the Ajna. Therefore, you may meditate upon any of the two centers according to your liking.

Question:
In dedicating your actions to God, should each action be preceded with that specific mental thought or is a general mental attitude to that effect enough?

Answer: It is better to practice this art of dedication by repeating your mantra and developing a special attitude prior to the performance of any work. While performing the work, you should remind yourself of your dedication again and again. This practice will create a spiritual habit. And later, there will be a spontaneous awareness of dedication that will permeate all the works that you do.

Question:
In the waking state, the ideal for eradicating negativity is by sublimation and being a witness to your thoughts. What can be done about gross tendencies that manifest during Dream State, when I tend to identify more with my thoughts? If I have a dream where I show violence, for example, should I not let it bother me and just wait for a time when my practices will carry over into dream?

Answer: The gross tendencies that manifest during dream state are based upon the subtle impressions (Vasanas) of the unconscious. One cannot deal with them directly. In the daily life, a plan is evolved by an aspirant to create positive impressions in the unconscious. By the practice of selfless action, Japa (repetition of Mantra or Divine Name), meditation, enquiry, and by a harmonized life, one continues to create positive impressions which in turn overpower the negative impressions. In the course of time, there arises a spiritual vision, which is unobstructed, whether one is dreaming or awake. Keeping this in view, you should not worry about such tendencies when they manifest in dream; rather, you should continue to intensify your effort in daily life of promoting positive impressions.

Question:
Which is a higher development--to be repulsed by anger, lust, etc., or just to see them as obstacles of the path to be overcome?

Answer: In the beginning you should learn to see the impurities of the mind as obstacles on the path, and reflect upon their harmful effects on your personality. As you advance, a sense of repugnance develops towards them, and therefore, whenever these tendencies begin to raise their heads you defy them immediately. For want of attention and support, they begin to die away and are sublimated into positive qualities. However, in this case, "repulsion" is not of a sentimental nature; rather, it is an expression of a healthy personality.

For example, a heavy smoker is delighted when someone smokes near him. He is tempted to join the smoking feast. But when he has quit the habit, he is no longer tempted by the smoke. Rather, he is repulsed by it. Similarly, when you renounce the habit of anger and other impurities, you develop repulsion towards them. Naturally this is a higher development. Still higher is a state where these impurities are rooted out and the mind is no longer concerned with opposing them or defying them.


Question:
We, as human beings, talk about love. How important is it that we love each other? Is it more important to have Divine Love than human
love?

Answer: Divine Love is the goal. Human love can become a means or a way to Divine Love, depending upon your understanding of the mystery of life. On the other hand, if human love is the ultimate in your personality, if you think that this is final, that this is all there is, then that love becomes confused. You cannot secure human love. However, you can have it and make it more beautiful by recognizing the Divine Love, which is behind it.

It is just like trying to kindle a fire. First you encounter smoke and sparks. That smoke is an important stage, and if you continue there will be fire. Human love is a kind of smoke. If you have Divine Love, human love becomes more meaningful, more profound. It is not selfish. But if you do not have Divine Love, human love becomes limited, entangling and creates bondage.

Question: Since no relationship is permanent, many people might feel that it is perfectly okay to end their relationships. This is what we're having so much of. The statement that no relationship is permanent disturbs me.

Answer: But that is just a statement of fact. No relationship is
permanent because no personality is permanent. You are not going to be permanent as the present personality; your partner is not going to be permanent as the present personality; so from that point of view no relationship is permanent. But, if there is Divine Love, every instance of human love develops on a deeper basis. If Divine Love is lacking, then human love becomes superficial and only creates bondage. Therefore, if people advance on the path of Bhakti Yoga, they become more loveable, more loving, and the goodness of their hearts unfolds more and more. They become more sacrificing in the acts of their love in every way.

Question: So would we be correct in thinking that human love is the same
as that which operates as the instinct of love.


Answer: The profoundest instinct of love is to love God; but it has become refracted and is expressed in every living being according to the nature of evolution. So the human being is capable of expressing love in many forms. Although an animal is capable of loving in one particular form, more at the biological level, the root-source behind all expressions of love is love of God.


Question:
What is your understanding of free choice and how does it operate?

Answer:
Free choice is awareness that you can change your conditions, that awareness develops when mind is purified. In Yoga terminology, it is when sattwa develops. When that happens, your personality is harmonized and there is more goodness, peace and contentment. You begin to discover that there is a mighty power within you and that you are really not helpless; you are capable of doing whatever you really want to do. So to the extent you allow sattwa to grow, to that extent you will experience freedom.

But if your mind becomes distracted, as happens in bad company, or when it is full of desires, or full of anger and hate, then you begin to develop the idea that you are bound by destiny and have no strength. So rajas promotes that reliance on destiny. When tamas arises, your mind is grossly involved in anger, violence, hypocrisy and other degrading sentiments, and you suffer the greatest loss of mental freedom.


Question:
The transcendental Self is entangled in this material condition because of ignorance. How can Brahman descend from this state of enlightenment and perfection into a state of ignorance, which is the cause of the world-process?

Answer:
In order to understand how Brahman descended into limitation, you must realize that the very question being asked, is being asked by an intellect which is in itself in a state of limitation. For example, suppose in your dream you ask the question as to where the snake (snake-in-the-rope) came from. That question is valid only in the Dream State. Similarly, if you consider the human predicament from the point of view of intuition, the questioning mind itself has to be treated instead of trying to find the answer.

If you have a lantern in your hands, don't look for darkness and ask where it came from or for how long it existed. The fact is, as you take the light and explore the darkness, to your surprise the darkness doesn't exist.

Similarly, Vedanta says to practice meditation and find the light. When that intuitional knowledge develops, then you realize that you were never really caught, that you were never really in a state of bondage. If you were really in a state of bondage, you could never be freed. So, the bondage has been an apparent development caused by a form of illusion, a form of misunderstanding. Vedanta calls it ignorance, and treating it requires philosophical discipline of the intellect. The moment you tax your intellect by asking why and when, the intellect becomes confused, saying such things as "Well, since even great people can't tell me why and when Brahman created this world, then why should I practice anything when everything is so confused?"


Question:
What are the characteristics of Shiva the Destroyer?

Answer:
Shiva is worshipped in two ways: Shiva the destroyer and Shiva the benevolent. Whichever aspect you worship, accordingly, that aspect will develop. If you are worshipping Him as the destroyer, then, again, you can worship Him in two ways, as the destroyer of physical objects or as the destroyer of psychological obstacles. So, by meditating on Shiva > as the psychological destroyer, you destroy attachments and subtle mental defects. By worshipping Shiva as the physical destroyer, it emulates the gross type of destruction and is a lesser type of worship. Desiring the destruction of enemies or fulfillment of an egoistic desire is a negative development.

When you are worshipping Vishnu, there, again, you have the possibility of adopting different attributes. If you adopt the attribute of grace, then you become graceful. If you adopt the attribute of power, then you become powerful, and through the attribute of knowledge, you gain knowledge--as Lord Vishnu is the embodiment of knowledge, power and grace. The attribute you acknowledge in God begins to develop in you.

Through the worship of Ganesha, you overcome obstacles and gain auspiciousness. Ganesha also, can give anything else, because He is a symbol of the same Absolute. His elephant form is symbolic of majesty; His large trunk is full of the intuitive movement of mind. He has only one tooth, or tusk, and it symbolizes nonduality. Everyone else has two teeth, those of raga and dwesha, attachment and hatred. In Him, His one tusk is broken, symbolizing His one aspected movement--duality has been broken. He has a gigantic body, symbolizing how He includes the entire universe. He sits on a rat, which is the symbol of intuitive vision that cuts into the subtle desires. He holds in one hand the sweets of liberation and in the other hand the book of knowledge.

So, every god that is presented in Hindu mysticism is surrounded with symbolism. All that you see around a god, his clothes, his every adornment, has symbolic meaning. Every god is the symbol of the Absolute. However, you have two choices of worship; if you are advanced, you worship the Absolute through a symbol. If you are not advanced then you worship that god for certain results and your worship is dictated by your ego. If it is dictated by your ego, then you are receiving perishable results. On the other hand, if you are worshipping for the sake of mental purification then it has imperishable results
.

Question:
I am having a very difficult time reconciling the explanation of how the world is derived from Brahman with the practical realities of daily life. I realize the problem lies in the fact that I am trying to understand it with a limited mind, but still there seems to be something missing. If Brahman is perfect and transcendental, then why project, even as a fancy, anything at all? Why should Cosmic Mind ever come about? How can there be an absolute law, such as karma, in a relative world? How can there be practical realities in an illusion? It just seems that if Brahman hadn't projected anything in the first place, there would be no ego, no world-process, and no need for Self-realization.

Answer: Intellectually it is difficult to reconcile with any explanation of the world offered by any philosophical system. However, the intention of Vedanta philosophy is to help you to develop intuitive vision. Intuitive vision is like waking up--once you wake up, you no longer seek the whereabouts of the objects seen in dream. This "waking up" is done by the practice of meditation and enquiry (reflection). Even in dream there are practical realities relative to the dream world, and when you wake up those realities become false. In the same way, there are "realities" in practical life--the sense of ego, the egoistic values, the perceptions of the objects, the Law of Karma, and others-- but when your mind is enlightened, all these become false, or mere appearances.

The realities of your childhood have become meaningless today. Similarly, the realities of a person who is filled with egoistic desires become meaningless when he rises above them. And again, the realities of this world become meaningless when the mind is enlightened. If a person who is frightened by a snake-in-a-rope were to say, "If the rope had not projected the illusion of the snake in the first place, I would not have been frightened," his statement would be as illusory as the snake-in-the-rope in the first place. Similar is your statement, "If Brahman had not projected the world in the first place..."

Generally speaking, it is only when faced with adversities that a person reflects, "If the world had not been projected, how wonderful it would be!" However, when there are prosperous conditions one does not entertain this type of thought. The intellect becomes confounded because it tries to negate only the negative aspect of the world. If the intellect were to see both, prosperity and adversity, in the same light, it would then be intuitive and the world would appear as the unruffled Ocean of Bliss.


Question:
The Gita states that when the three gunas are transcended, a yogi is not affected by them. In explaining this, you said that sattwa helps the luminous state of mind and that tamas helps to sustain that peaceful state. If a sage has transcended the gunas, how do they still exist for him?

Answer:
The human personality is composed of the three gunas (sattwa, rajas, and tamas), and is constantly influenced by them. Even after Enlightenment, the personality of a sage is maintained by his fructifying karma (prarabdha karma). But, though living in a body, a sage transcends the body. You may live in a house and yet move in and out of it. In the same way, a sage exists in the body and yet is beyond it. Transcending the body does not mean that the body becomes non-existent. Similarly, transcending the gunas does not imply the cessation of the gunas. The gunas continue to exist as long as the body lasts, but they do not obstruct the intuitive vision of the sage. In the state of bondage, a person is affected by the gunas. Sattwa causes attachment to pleasure. Rajas creates dislike or hatred towards pain. Tamas drags a person to a state of dullness and gross-mindedness.

When the personality is disciplined, however, the very same gunas begin to help an aspirant in his spiritual movement. Sattwa gives opportunity for inner reflection and meditation. Rajas provides energy for performing karma yoga (selfless action). And tamas provides physical and mental rest. In the case of an enlightened sage, these gunas become transformed into mystic processes that glorify that state of realization. As long as a sage has a body, the three gunas continue to operate in his personality. However, he is not affected by them. If you are flying in a plane beyond the clouds, it does not matter whether the clouds are dense, silvery or become thinly dispersed. But if you fly below the clouds, the variations of clouds will affect the plane. In the same way,the variations in gunas do not affect a sage who is beyond them.

On the other hand, the gunas serve a different purpose in a sage. Sattwa continues to fill his mind with luminous thoughts. Rajas enables him to perform actions for the well-being of all and tamas gives needed rest to his body while creating an inertia of a higher type. If the experience of a higher state becomes steady through inertia, that form of inertia is divine. This is what happens to a sage.

NEXT PAGE